Speculative Art Shows

We travel a lot, and we also love art, specifically “street art”. As I’m writing this Sunday’s Thoughts, I’m in Warsaw visiting the excellent AVS, and in a few weeks we’ll head to Madrid for the Art and Sound Fest, a high-end audio show that promises to incorporate modern art. And we do collect the odd bit of art; nothing overly extravagant, just stuff we like. Over the years, we’ve been to a whole load of art shows, and we’ve met a lot of wonderful people along the way. Collectors, enthusiasts, artists…the lot. But lately, perhaps there’s been a bit of a trend that’s becoming increasingly concerning: the speculative event.

You’ll know the kind of thing I mean. An announcement might go out with great fanfare. Dates are given, a venue is named, and perhaps a few dealer and gallery logos appear on a holding page…possibly an artist whose work we collect or want to see more of might be there. There’s a flurry of excitement. The collectors and more casual visitors start making plans. Then, as the date creeps closer, a polite message appears: “We regret to inform you…” or “Postponed until next year…” And suddenly, it’s off. Cancelled. Quietly brushed aside until next year, when the whole cycle might start again. Damn! 

From the outside, it may not appear to be a significant issue. Venues fall through, costs spiral, logistics get tricky; all fair enough. But when you dig a bit deeper, these speculative announcements can cause real and lasting damage.

Let’s start with the visitors and collectors. You see an event advertised that looks right up your street, though not literally; there’s work you want to see, and you might even consider making a purchase. You book time off work. You arrange cat care. You sort out travel, maybe even buy tickets. Perhaps you plan to make a weekend of it: a hotel, a meal out, a chance to meet like-minded souls and maybe pick up something special for your growing collection. You might even buddy up with friends to share petrol. Then, just before the big day, it’s gone. The anticipation turns to disappointment, and the next time you see an Art Show announced, you think twice before committing. And who could blame you?

Now picture the exhibitors. They’ve got fixed annual budgets for shows. They’ve potentially booked staff, designed displays, printed banners, and spent money on promotion. They may even have commissioned new pieces especially for the event. When the rug gets pulled, that money doesn’t come back. Neither does the time nor the effort. It’s not just frustrating…it’s costly.

Of course, I can see why art show organisers sometimes take this approach. Booking a venue outright can be expensive (we know, we run Audio Show Deluxe, which I’d argue isn’t that different), and if the exhibitor numbers or visitor interest aren’t there, it’s a gamble. Perhaps they float the idea first, see who signs up, and only later decide whether to proceed. It’s understandable on paper, but in reality, it’s short-term thinking that chips away at wider trust.

And in any specialist field, whether it’s art, antiques, records, or, say, home audio equipment, trust is everything. Events thrive on relationships: organisers rely on exhibitors, exhibitors rely on visitors, and the whole thing relies on everyone believing that what’s announced will actually happen. Once that confidence starts to waver, it spreads.

People begin to hesitate before booking. Exhibitors become cautious about committing funds. Visitors wait until the last minute before buying tickets. Momentum fades, and the sense of community that makes these gatherings so enjoyable begins to erode. Before long, even genuinely well-organised events suffer because everyone’s become a little wary.

And here’s the rub: when these shows vanish at the eleventh hour, it’s not just a few disappointed collectors who lose out; it’s the whole scene. The excitement fades, the buzz quietens, and the credibility that keeps a specialist community alive starts to slip away.

In niche industries, reputation travels faster than any marketing campaign. When an event collapses close to its date, people remember. Whispers start: “Do you think this one’s really happening?” and before long, the shadow of doubt falls over even the most reliable organisers. Those who play it (what I consider to be) straight find themselves paying the price for those who didn’t.

The irony is that everyone involved wants the same thing: vibrant, well-run events where exhibitors and gallery owners meet engaged visitors and collectors, ideas are shared, and the art community comes alive. But speculative announcements threaten that. They create uncertainty where there should be excitement, and hesitation where there should be enthusiasm.

The solution isn’t complicated. Don’t announce what isn’t certain. Secure the venue, confirm the dates, get the basics right, and then tell the world. People understand that events are complex to organise; they just need to know that when something’s announced, it’s real.

Speculative events might seem harmless, even optimistic, but in truth, they do more harm than good. They damage trust, strain relationships, and make life harder for everyone who genuinely wants the industry – sorry, the Art World (as they like to call it) – to flourish.

And without that trust, what’s left? A few empty halls, a handful of disappointed visitors, and a lot of people wondering if it’s worth bothering next time.

Stuart Smith

Read More Sunday Thoughts.

What do you think? Join the conversation over on Facebook.